Mike Mussina: Hall of Famer?

I'm torn.

The positives

Excluding his rookie season, (in which he only pitched in 12 games) the guy never had a only had one losing season in 17 years of MLB service.

He logged a lifetime .638 winning percentage. Wow.

The negatives

He only had one 20-win season.

He never won a Cy Young Award.

At no point in a nearly 20-year career did he ever seem like the dominant pitcher of his time.

In my mind, too many players get into the Hall of Fame. I say NO to Mussina...
- posted by Brian @ 12:25 PM